Here’s an issue I’m torn on: electing judges.
On the one hand, I support giving people much more direct control over their government. On the other hand, it’s tough to know who all these people are, much less, what the position is that they are running for.
What I do know is that the present system contains within it opportunities for the appearance of impropriety. Case in point is today’s Sheila Burke article in the Tennessean:
Fundraising receptions for some of Nashville’s soon-to-be-judges are drawing fire from critics, who question why lawyers who would come before the judges’ courts are being asked to pay up.
These unopposed candidates are trying to pay off their campaign debts — or pay back their own funds that they’ve sunk into their races — by having fundraisers at which donors, many of them lawyers, are asked to give money.
And while there’s nothing legally wrong with the practice, which is said to be commonplace, some think it just looks plain bad and further undermines confidence in the courts.
Others wonder whether the receptions are tantamount to buying justice.
. . . “If attorneys are dumping money into unopposed judicial races, it certainly raises suspicion that Tennessee’s legal system may also be for sale,” [said TN Center for Policy Research president, Drew Johnson.]
A couple months ago, local blogger and attorney Roger Abramson wrote about why he wasn’t even voting in the May judges primary. He laid out a good case for why there shouldn’t be partisan judicial races.
. . . there’s just something unseemly about someone who is supposed to be impartial on the job going around trolling for votes from people and getting endorsements from groups. For similar reasons, I also have a real problem with judges running under partisan banners.
As for me, I haven’t yet early voted. I know who I’m voting for in all of the races on the first page of the ballot, but I haven’t had time to figure out what to do with many of the judicial races.
Are partisan judicial races, and our current system of election funding a problem? If so, what are potential solutions?
Share This